Why Anderson Insurance Agency?

Anderson insurance agency was formed in 1967 with its headquarters in Manahawkin New Jersey. Our mission is to provide our clients with a choice of coverages from a variety of insurance companies to best fulfill their insurance needs and budget.


In addition to our extensive experience, here are five more advantages to choosing us:

Superior Customer Service

Unlike others, we won’t simply refer you to an 800 number. Call us instead at 609-597-8507 at any time 24/7/365 and we’ll take full ownership of your claim.

Flood Expertise

Many national insurers and local agencies shy away from flood insurance. Not us. In fact, we’re honored to have been named National Flood Insurance Program Agent of the Year.

Better Pricing

We’re fully independent. So we can shop your coverage needs to any of over 35 top-rated underwriters to help find the best value for you.

Tri-State Convenience

We regularly write policies for home and business owners throughout New Jersey, Pennsylvania and Delaware.

Fast Results

We’ve gotten to know most local contractors, mortgage lenders and real estate agents. Should any concerns on insurance surface, we can quickly resolve them on your behalf.

Community Involvement

Every day, we make it a point to be good neighbors in the communities we serve. In part, that means providing friendly, personalized products and service to protect what you value most, from your home to your business. It also means getting involved in the good works of the many amazing organizations that protect and create the amazing way of life that defines the Jersey Shore.


Long Beach Island Historical Association
Marine Mammal Stranding Center
MATES Program
National Multiple Scleroses Foundation
New Jersey Maritime Museum
Ship Bottom Irish Festival
Hunger Foundation of Southern Ocean
Southern Ocean Rotary

4 Scholarships to Southern Regional High School Graduates Annually
Atlantic City Historical Society
Barnegat Light Vol. Fire Co.
CarEing for Children
David’s Dream and Believe Foundation
Heritage Harvest Foundation
Jetty Foundation
Long Beach Island Foundation of the Arts and Sciences

St. Francis Community Center
St. Jude’s
Stafford PBA
Stafford Township Historical Society
Stafford Township Vol. Fire Co.
Stafford Wrestling
Tuckerton Seaport
And over 50 other worthy causes!


Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of New Jersey
Marine Trades Association of New Jersey
Ocean County Business Association
Better Business Bureau – A+ Rating
Professional Insurance Agents of New Jersey

Welcome to Anderson Insurance Agency!

Our commitment to customer service has helped us expand our coverage area across the entire state of NJ. Now, we are a part of the McMahon Insurance Agency, expanding coverage even further. Our staff here on the Jersey Shore has made us the most trusted independent insurance agency for those who love to live with peace of mind that you expect from your insurance agent.

It doesn’t matter if your get-around is on four wheels, two wheels or a center console; AIA is there to insure you. Whether your home is an inland safe haven or a coastal retreat, we cover it. Seasonal businesses, year-round offices and mainland retail establishments all count on AIA to protect their assets. Medical professionals, builders and professional services providers rely on AIA to protect their lives and livelihoods.

Seeking great people to join our team

Want to join our talented team? Anderson Insurance is a leading provider of property casualty insurance for auto, home, and business. Our success is built upon our ability to provide innovative insurance and risk protection products and services that meet our customers’ needs. We pride ourselves on helping customers manage risk before a claim occurs and responding with speed, professionalism and compassion when claims do happen.

Anderson Insurance Agency has operations in Manahawkin New Jersey and offers its customers a wide range of coverages as well as specialized risk control services to help individuals and business owners protect against the unexpected.